Essays · Leadership · Psychology · Education

Why every leader needs to understand behavior like a psychologist

I trained as a school psychologist before I ran a school. Here is why leaders who read behavior as information make better calls about people.

I trained as a school psychologist before I ever ran a building, and that order shaped everything about how I led.

I started as a special education teacher and school psychologist in Columbia and St. Louis County, Missouri. Then I spent five years in Belleville, Illinois, as a school psychologist, counselor, and dean of students. Only after that did I become a principal, then an assistant superintendent, an area superintendent in Houston, and a superintendent in Mississippi. I am a nationally certified school psychologist, I still practice, and the company I founded, MindAble Solutions, is a school psychology and education technology company serving districts in Missouri, Kansas, Mississippi, Michigan, and Tennessee.

Here is what that path taught me. Most of what lands on a leader’s desk is behavior. The report that is late again. The principal who stops returning calls. The department that drags its feet on a new initiative. The student sent to the office for the fourth time this month.

The leader’s first instinct is to name it: lazy, resistant, not a team player. The psychologist’s first instinct is to ask what the behavior is telling you.

The words that explain nothing

“Lazy.” “Unmotivated.” “Doesn’t care.” “Not a self-starter.”

We use these words about students, employees, and ourselves. They feel like explanations. They are not. They describe what we can see from the outside, someone not doing the thing, and then they guess at why. Usually they guess wrong.

In my book Whispering Shadows, I put it this way: not starting is a behavior, not a diagnosis. The real question is what is making the start so hard.

When you look closely, there are at least five common reasons people do not start:

  1. They expect to be judged. The task feels like a test of their worth, so avoiding it keeps the verdict on hold.
  2. They are overwhelmed. The task looks like a mountain with no visible path.
  3. They do not know how. A skill or a piece of information is missing, and they are embarrassed to ask.
  4. Something practical is in the way. Not enough time, a missing tool, conflicting instructions from two bosses, a sick parent at home.
  5. They truly are not interested. This one is real too, and worth taking seriously.

Notice that only some of these are about mindset. If someone needs instructions, no pep talk will fill that gap. If someone is working two jobs, they do not need a new attitude. They need time.

Psychologists Fuschia Sirois and Timothy Pychyl have argued that procrastination is often less a time-management problem than a mood problem. Putting off a task that makes us anxious or insecure buys immediate relief, and the bill comes due later. That is why “Why don’t you care?” gets nowhere, and “What feeling does this task bring up?” sometimes gets the truth.

What the referral folder taught me

A lot of the referrals I receive begin with some version of the same sentence: capable, but just not motivated.

I have learned to treat that sentence as a starting point, not a conclusion. When I actually evaluate the student, the data often points somewhere else. Sometimes there may be a reading difficulty, and every assignment takes three times as long. Sometimes there are signs of attention or organization challenges. Sometimes the student seems so worried about getting it wrong that not trying feels safer. Sometimes the barrier is practical, like caring for younger siblings every afternoon with no quiet place to work.

“Not motivated” was the explanation offered for all of them. In my experience, that label rarely helps anyone get the right support. When we name the actual barrier, the help can finally match the problem.

A note of caution, because it matters. Leaders should not diagnose anyone. If a pattern raises questions about a child’s learning or well-being, the right step is the school team, the pediatrician, or a licensed professional. Your job as a leader is not to put a name on what is happening inside a person. It is to stop putting the wrong name on it.

Behavior follows structure

When I consult with schools, I sometimes ask a question that makes adults pause: when does this student hear from the principal’s office?

For many students referred for behavior concerns, the honest answer is: only when something is wrong. Every call, every meeting, every message home is about a problem. So, naturally, they learn to expect a problem, and they arrive at the office already braced for a fight.

I have seen schools change that with small, deliberate moves. Calling students to the office to deliver good news, and saying so in the announcement. Making positive calls home a regular habit instead of a rare surprise. Greeting students by name in the hallway. Building predictable routines for discipline, so students know what will happen and why.

None of that erases a student’s history. It gives the student new data. And new data is what slowly changes an old expectation.

The same is true for adults. If the only time your team hears from you is when something is broken, do not be surprised when “Got a minute?” makes people’s stomachs drop.

The superintendent’s version

As a superintendent, I learned that every policy is a bet about behavior. A tardy rule, a grading policy, an evaluation system, a new initiative: each one predicts how people will respond and quietly shapes how they do.

Leaders who understand behavior ask different questions before they sign. What will people expect this means, based on how we have acted before? What barrier might keep a good person from following it? Who will this make look “unmotivated” when the real problem is something we built?

A better conversation

If someone on your team keeps missing deadlines, the easiest explanation is that they do not care. It is also the least useful. It makes people defensive and rarely leads to a fix.

Try a different opening. “I’ve noticed the reports have been late the last two quarters. I don’t think it’s because you don’t care. Help me understand what makes this one hard to start.”

Then listen. You may hear that the data comes from three systems that do not talk to each other, or that nobody ever explained what a good report looks like. You cannot fix a barrier you never asked about.

The next play

  • The next time you reach for “lazy” or “resistant,” write down the behavior in plain words instead: what happened, when, and how often.
  • Run the five reasons against it and note which ones might be true. Treat this as a tool for reflection, not a clinical measure.
  • Ask one person, “What makes this hard to start?” and then stop talking.
  • Look at your last ten messages to the people you lead. Count how many were about a problem and how many were good news.
  • Make one call this week for good news only.